star tribune movie reviews

Review: Pixar's 'Elemental' is a romantic but murky mix of fire and water

The opposites-attract love story is a winner but the setting has some confusing dilemmas.

By Chris Hewitt

"Elemental" is the most emotional Pixar movie since "Inside Out," and the hardest to make sense of.

It's a full-on romance, set in a world where characters belong to one of four groups that pretty much stick to themselves: fire, water, earth and air. Main characters Ember (fire) and Wade (water) fall in love — "When I met you, I thought I was drowning, but that light inside you has made me so alive," is how Wade puts it. Voice actors Leah Lewis and Mamoudou Athie, respectively, bring huge depths of feeling to their performances as a couple whose communities — especially Ember's traditional parents — don't approve.

Pixar has sometimes been shy about love stories, but that's the part of "Elemental" that works best. That has a lot to do with director Peter Sohn's willingness to commit to the central romance, which has humor but gets into pretty dark emotional territory for both of its unmoored main characters, whose parents are not wrong when they point out the tremendous differences between them.

It also has to do with the clever character design. In the time-honored cartoon tradition of Squidward, Winnie-the-Pooh and Donald Duck, Wade wears a shirt but no pants. But, otherwise, these are very untraditional characters. It could seem like a drawback that both Ember and Wade are visually amorphous — the flames that constitute her body and the water that makes up his are in constant motion — but they're always clearly these two vivid, passionate characters.

What works less well in "Elemental" is the fuzzy central idea. The four-elements thing wants to be a metaphor for immigration, with some of the elements feeling less-than and unwelcomed by some of the others. We're certainly accustomed to storytelling that presents cross-cultural lovers from different worlds — Romeo and Juliet, Tony and Maria , Ariel and Prince Eric from the current "Little Mermaid."

But, unlike in the well-defined concept of "Inside Out" or the slightly less clear one in "Soul," the "Elemental" territories are so amorphous that we aren't sure what their rules are, especially since Ember and Wade genuinely do seem to have an issue that makes it impossible for them to be together: A well-tossed bucket of him will put her out forever and it wouldn't take much of her to make him evaporate.

Just a couple of minor but confusing dilemmas: A running joke is that the water people cry all the time, but so does Ember. What's that about? And earth and air are clearly important elements, but both are virtually ignored in "Elemental." All of this makes you feel like the movie might work better with human characters, who wouldn't always be at one or two allegorical removes from the story that's being told.

The murkiness is not a deal-breaker by any means. I was moved by Ember and Wade's romance and "Elemental" has flashes of insight into the complicated bonds between immigrant parents and first-generation children.

But I have to admit my mind kept going back to "Carl's Date," the brief "Up" sequel that plays before "Elemental" and that stands out for its simplicity and warmth. Is it wrong of me to wish I were watching a full-length version of that, instead?

'Elemental'

*** out of 4 stars

Related Coverage

Rated : PG for animated destruction and danger.

Where : In theaters Friday.

about the writer

Chris hewitt.

Interim books editor Chris Hewitt previously worked at the Pioneer Press in St. Paul, where he wrote about movies and theater.

More from Movies

The biggest ‘deadpool & wolverine’ cameos, explained.

The mega Marvel hit did not just bring back Ryan Reynolds and Hugh Jackman but also quite a few familiar faces.

An evening at the Long Drive-In, one of the last drive-in theaters in Minnesota

Long Prairie’s idyllic outdoor movie shrine, now in its 68th season, is one of five remaining drive-ins in the state.

Review: ‘Deadpool & Wolverine’ is dull and thin. And also nonsensical and silly.

Ryan Reynolds (Deadpool) and Hugh Jackman (Wolverine) squabble endlessly, engaging in meaningless fights and words.

Today's news
Reviews and deals
Climate change
2024 election
Newsletters
Fall allergies
Health news
Mental health
Sexual health
Family health
So mini ways
Unapologetically
Buying guides

Entertainment

How to Watch
My watchlist
Stock market
Biden economy
Personal finance
Stocks: most active
Stocks: gainers
Stocks: losers
Trending tickers
World indices
US Treasury bonds
Top mutual funds
Highest open interest
Highest implied volatility
Currency converter
Basic materials
Communication services
Consumer cyclical
Consumer defensive
Financial services
Industrials
Real estate
Mutual funds
Credit cards
Balance transfer cards
Cash back cards
Rewards cards
Travel cards
Online checking
High-yield savings
Money market
Home equity loan
Personal loans
Student loans
Options pit
Fantasy football
Pro Pick 'Em
College Pick 'Em
Fantasy baseball
Fantasy hockey
Fantasy basketball
Download the app
Daily fantasy
Scores and schedules
GameChannel
World Baseball Classic
Premier League
CONCACAF League
Champions League
Motorsports
Horse racing

New on Yahoo

Privacy Dashboard

Review: Pierre delivers star-making turn in action thriller ‘Rebel Ridge’

Good acting, breathtaking action and a compelling narrative makes the movie thrilling to watch.

Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz has not said abortion in ninth month is ‘absolutely fine’

Donald Trump attacked Kamala Harris’ vice presidential nominee from the debate stage Tuesday, but his claims are inaccurate and misleading.

Family points to reason behind fatal collapse of runner at Minneapolis half marathon

Ramsey county narrows probe into former medical examiner to seven cases, trump said minneapolis burned down, so minnesotans sarcastically posted about the ‘ash and destruction’, employee accused of stealing, reselling $40k in outdoor gear, guns from walker, minn., store, from opinion: ‘they’re eating the dogs. … they’re eating the cats’ — racist stereotypes that hurt immigrant communities, downtown st. paul is having a moment — but not a good one.

Beloved restaurants have closed and office buildings sold at discount, raising alarms about the future of the capital city’s urban core.

Review: With special effects buzzing, ‘Back to the Future’ bends time at Minneapolis’ Orpheum Theatre

The musical adaptation of the 1985 film is chock-full of special effects that make the music sometimes seem like second fiddle.

RandBall: Stats told the story for Sam Darnold and Kirk Cousins. But so did their feet.

Breakdowns of what went right and wrong in Week 1 for the current and past Vikings quarterbacks revealed some encouraging signs for Sam Darnold and some concerns about Kirk Cousins.

It’s booya season: Where to find these once-a-year events

Every year folks line up for this special stew and the community it fosters.

Greater Minnesota

Rochester could get new 14-story building that includes student housing downtown.

The proposed 175,000-square foot building could provide more than 200 housing units for area college students.

Minneapolis man admits role in fatal shooting in downtown Rochester during fight over dice game

An accomplice was sentenced earlier in connection with the killing of a 28-year-old man.

Prosecutors say Kelsey Marie Rutland used gift cards at Reeds, her former employer, to carry out 40 fraudulent purchases, including 18 firearms.

Thomas Rhett and Jordan Davis will headline Winstock 2025

Ramstad: financial aid crisis ends, but shrinking market looms for minnesota colleges, essentia health to drop from medicare advantage networks at unitedhealthcare, humana, bar brawl in montevideo leads to attempted murder charge, five arrests, we heard what they did. still waiting on what they’d do..

Minnesota Star Tribune Editorial Board members weigh in on the Trump-Harris debate.

Four of the Minnesota Star Tribune’s contributing columnists weigh in on Tuesday’s debate.

Made (cool) in Minnesota

From opinion: violent threats against black women leaders are no joking matter, strib voices.

Food & Culture

When making tomato sauce, fresh is best

The ingredient list for Buttered Fresh Tomato Sauce is short, but the flavor is big.

Wilco books another rare three-night stand in St. Paul, this one even more special

The big gigs: 10 best concerts to see in twin cities this week, tv dinners: try these recipes from your favorite shows.

Gov. Tim Walz reacts to ‘fellow cat owner’ Taylor Swift’s endorsement

Minneapolis neighbors attacked family homeless shelter residents, agency says

Scheels, employee sued over teen’s suicide in Eden Prairie store

Games & Comics

CHS returning $600 million to cooperative owners

The cash payments and equity redemption will be the third-highest patronage payouts on record for the Minnesota-based coop.

Essentia Health wins arbitration dispute over control of Fosston hospital

Community leaders in northwest Minnesota town opposed Duluth-based health system’s decision to close labor and delivery services.

Downtown St. Paul property owners OK expansion of privately funded safety services

Ellison announces settlement between asylum-seekers, law firm.

FACT FOCUS: A look at false and misleading claims made during Trump and Harris' debate

Taylor Swift endorses Kamala Harris for president after debate ends

Curious minnesota.

How did Old Dutch potato chips get started in St. Paul?

What happened to the frozen whale that used to visit the State Fair?

How the State Fair’s mascot was inspired by a real-life Fairchild

Minnesotans focus on the sky as International Observe the Moon Night approaches

Jeff Tweedy with keyboardist Mikael Jorgensen and drummer Glenn Kotche during Wilco's three-night Palace Theatre run in November 2017. / Jeff Wheeler, Star Tribune

Summer tourists in Europe hit with heatwaves, wildfires and an eruption

How two Lake Michigan beach towns became a ‘little Midwestern gay mecca’

A houseboat getaway on the Mississippi tunes in to the Great River’s rhythms

Health care.

‘This is not a bill’: How to decipher explanations of benefits and pay for your medical care

Wisconsin health officials recall eggs after a multistate salmonella outbreak

Outdoor activities.