Once I got to a size 16 I just got kinda lazy and went ‘well, I'm fine now’, do you know. I'd, I would like to lose a wee bit more but I'm quite content the way I am do you know
However, some participants expressed current acceptance of their size. For example, Geoff (‘relapser’) was not ‘ overly concerned ’, having decided ‘ this is what I'm are ’ [sic], Christina (‘stable’) described herself as ‘ quite vain, even though I'm big, I think I'm shit hot’ and Jenny (‘stable’) did not want to ‘ go to all these classes to get healthy. As long as I don't feel like crap I'm not too bothered like ’. Two ‘slimmers’ expressed acceptance only once they felt more comfortable with their clothes size. Eilidh described herself as becoming ‘ lazy’ and ‘ content ’ on reaching size 16, and Rachel ‘ realised as I got older that I was never supposed to be a size six or a size eight, that's just not the way I'm built ’.
In response to these concerns, almost all participants described behavioural changes, including diet (next section) and exercise, particularly in gyms, but also team sports, swimming, use of home exercise DVDs/gym equipment, running and walking ( table 3 ; see online supplementary table S2).
Illustrative quotes according to participant ‘slimmer’, ‘relapser’, ‘stable’ and ‘gainer’ categorisation—exercise and diet
Slimmers | |
Mark | I don't remember the moment of making the decision, but I do remember coming home from school and getting changed and going to the gym and that was, that was very… it was a bit of a departure from the way life was for me before then … it became part of my life and it has remained so to this day |
Catherine | So aye, it was losing the weight, it was, it was hard at the start, but see once you get into a routine of knowing what you do, what you can eat, what you can't eat, what you need to keep yourself away fae, it is quite easy |
Relapsers | |
Geoff | When I left school I went to I done, I done boxing, fitba, I went to the gym. … I wis I say I wis playing aw the sports. So if I could eat that but I, I wisny putting on any weight cos I wis going to the gym, playing fitba and that. I don't play a lot o’ fitba noo right enough. I'd like tae but it's getting the time and the people tae play it |
Laura | Maybe in the last couple of years or so, in the sense that, yeah, you go out and do lunches with your friends and this and that, and you think that I could really do with cutting some of that out. You know, weekend fry-ups and stuff like that. Trying to be healthier and, you know, the healthy option … |
Stable | |
Chris | I never did anything particularly excessive. I never did anything too… you know, tried… sort of stuck to anything very long I don't think when I was, when I was younger, so I guess that's probably why nothing ever worked |
Jenny | I can just eat really good foods and be really good but it never makes that much of a difference |
Gainers | |
Anne | I used to go to the gym on a Monday but it's shut now, the gym that I go to, it's not opened anymore. Em, for refurbishment. But like, I've got like exercise DVDs now that I'll do in the house |
Jamie | Just cut out junk, I cut out a lot of carbs I remember… Yeah it was that what I did I remember doing, I remember saying ‘no junk’… You really do need a disciplined and healthy eating plan. You know says the man who had a bag of crisps and a Mars Bar last night … |
Most ‘slimmers’ mentioned the gym. Pete and Mark started attending while still at school, which for Mark was ‘ a bit of a departure from the way life was for me before ’. Scott's, Charlie's, Claire's and Rachel's gym attendance began at university. Charlie found it ‘ wasn't even difficult ’ and this ‘ total change in lifestyle ’ resulted in weight loss. Claire used the gym ‘ throughout my uni life ’, and Rachel managed gym attendance, university classes and bar work. Exercise had been sustained by all this group. For Mark, the gym environment ‘ became part of my life and has remained so to this day ’, Scott continued to ‘ train hard ’ and Charlie described how ‘ now I jist sorta sustain ’ exercise. Claire's exercise had become ‘ kind of habit … I don't think I have to go to the gym or do this, to exercise I would just do, walking, jogging, whatever ’ and Rachel went ‘ to the gym a lot ’. Among the other ‘slimmers’, Emma's police training involved time at the gym, circuits and swimming and was ‘ the most active I think I have ever been in my life ’; she also continued to attend. Eilidh and Catherine had tried a gym, but preferred other activities; Eilidh ‘ loved’ cycling and Catherine walked with her baby buggy. While acknowledging impact on weight, Nina and Noel were vaguer about their exercise.
Some ‘relapsers’ linked weight loss to exercise. At around 17–18, Patricia ‘ lost a drastic amount of weight … and I was exercising an awful lot ’, Colin had a ‘ fitness freak stage ’ and Geoff found he could maintain his weight by balancing eating with exercise. However, only Patricia's gym attendance continued. Exercise featured less in the accounts of other ‘relapsers’, including Malcolm, for whom ‘ there's not been any exercise really, not much ’, Laura, who occasionally used a home trampoline, although ‘ there's just those weeks when you can't be bothered ’, and Donna who had recently tried to increase her exercise via walking. Similarly, Chris (‘stable’) thought not sticking with anything was ‘ probably why nothing ever worked ’ while Christina who regularly walked her dog ‘ wouldnae go tae a gym ’.
In exactly the same way, several male ‘gainers’ described earlier periods of significant exercise which had ceased for reasons, including the need to focus on academic work, injuries, lack of time or motivation. Some female ‘gainers’ described exercising: Anne had attended a gym which was now closed, but used home exercise DVDs, Elizabeth had discovered aqua-aerobics and Kirsty had recently joined a gym.
Participants tended to discuss diet in two ways. First, the importance of having a balanced diet that used home cooking rather than relying on frozen/take-away meals, with healthy choices such as less cheese or cream-based sauces and more fruit. Second, they described their experiences of participating in calorie-controlled diets, either as promoted by commercial slimming clubs or unsustainable ‘fad’ diets (eg, liquid diets, drinking vinegar, avoiding dairy/gluten/carbohydrates or foods of a particular colour) ( table 3 ; see online supplementary table S3 ).
Several female ‘slimmers’ related their weight loss to reduced food intake and meal-skipping: Rachel ‘ just changed the way I ate ’. Many ‘slimmers’ described the need to be constantly mindful of food choices: Mark had not bought certain foods in order to control his intake; Scott self-monitored, ‘ there's times whereby I'll pick up a biscuit and I'll go “no, I don't want it”’ ; Nina noted ‘ the [weight-related] worrying's definitely stayed there ’; and Eilidh described herself as ‘ very, very always watching about not getting bigger ’. However, some appeared slightly more relaxed, including Catherine who described ‘ a routine of knowing what you do, what you can eat, what you can't eat, what you need to keep yourself away fae. It is quite easy ’.
A similar range of strategies was described by participants in the other groups, but with perhaps less emphasis on real and sustainable reductions in intake or continued vigilance. Among the ‘relapsers’, Patricia had lost weight by meal skipping, Donna had achieved weight loss via severe dieting but now ate ‘healthy’ food, while one of Colin's adolescent weight-loss strategies had been to make himself sick; this had stopped and he was trying to ‘ eat something a bit more healthier ’. Malcolm believed controlling food intake was more important than exercise for weight loss, but did so by skipping breakfast. He and Philip talked about home-cooked meals while Laura mentioned ‘ you know, the healthy option ’. Christina (‘stable’) noted that ‘ I dae eat quite healthily but it's my amounts ’; she had unsuccessfully tried a range of ‘fad’ diets. However, Jenny (stable) believed ‘ I can just eat really good foods and be really good but it never makes that much of a difference ’.
Two ‘gainers’, Sarah and Kirsty, had recently started seriously dieting, using commercial slimming club regimes. Elizabeth reported losing weight when on a commercial club diet, and was currently focusing on ‘ watch[ing] what I'm eating ’, but Anne believed dieting had caused stomach problems so ‘ I'd had to eat things to suit my stomach, rather than suit my diet ’. Lisa also reported losing weight via a commercial club, but it increased once she ‘ stopped recording things and checkin g’. Although more often described by females, a small number of male ‘gainers’ also described dieting: Michael had reduced his calorie intake on the advice of his GP, and Richard ‘ didn't have a takeaway for six mon ths’, but then, to use Jamie's description, his diet went ‘ a bit awry again ’.
Contrasting with self-initiated and/or unsupported behavioural changes, professional support (eg, slimming clubs, fitness classes, GP advice) was mentioned by very few participants ( table 4 ; see online supplementary table S4 ). Only one ‘slimmer’, Pete, mentioned that at around age 19–20, he had asked his GP and been helped by simple advice on portion control, exercise and social support. Patricia (‘relapser’) reported her GP had told her ‘ och it's OK you don't need to lose weight ’. She had also attended a council-run weight-management service, Weight-Watchers and used a personal trainer.
Illustrative quotes according to participant ‘slimmer’, ‘relapser’, ‘stable’ and ‘gainer’ categorisation—professional support
Slimmer | |
Pete | I went to you know like my GP a couple of times to try and get advice on how to, you know what I should do. … [was advised] just to try and control portions and try to, to count, you know not count calories but be mindful of what the intake was and perhaps to, to exercise regularly you know with, either with friends or you know try and get support you know. So that did help a lot. That did help |
Relapser | |
Patricia | I was referred to the Council's weight-management service by my doctor, and I went and never lost any weight there, and because I never lost any weight, they just never got back in contact. And my doctor I feel because she's so big, when I go and I say ‘I would really, really like to lose weight and I'll, I can show you a food diary of what I've been eating, I can show you my exercise, I can show you how much water I've been drinking’, my doctor will go, ‘och it's ok you don't need to lose weight’ |
Gainers | |
Lisa | I went to Weight Watchers classes and lost a good bit of weight … the reason I left was a lot of it was getting me down because, em, there was too much emphasis on figures, like you've lost or you've gained or you're this or you're that |
Richard | My cousin dragged me tae Weight Watchers. … It's actually alright. I liked it. I went for aboot four months … I've got a family doctor … She's always geeing me an earful to get oan at me, and every time I go up that's the first thing she does. If I go up for a sore throat she weighs me, so she's always on my back to get me to lose weight. … So I've no been up for aboot eight month noo, coz I'm terrified of going up again in case she shouts at me again |
Similar, if not more, professional input was mentioned by ‘gainers’, some describing this as helpful. Anne spoke vaguely about ‘slimming clubs’, but Lisa lost ‘ a good bit of weight ’ via 2 years' Weight-Watchers attendance. Richard reported losing around 15 kg, having been ‘ dragged ’ to Weight-Watchers. However, he subsequently regained the weight and stopped attending his GP because ‘ She's always geeing me an earful to get oan at me, and every time I go up that's the first thing she does. If I go up for a sore throat she weighs me, so she's always on my back to get me to lose weight ’. Similarly, Michael reported his GP said ‘ if I keep cerry on the way I was, I was gonna have a heart attack by the time I was thirty-five, and that put the shitters right up me ’. However, he found her simple dietary and exercise advice useful. Two ‘gainers’ had started attending slimming clubs only very recently, with Kirsty reporting that ‘ I'm ready to take that step to lose weight ’.
Participants had experienced a range of young adult transitions: 23 had attended tertiary education in the past (university and college, including college-based apprenticeships) and 4 were doing so at the time of the interview; 29 were working and 5 had performed so in the past; 19 were living in their own homes and 3 had left the parental home in the past but were living back there at the time of the interview; 1 was a parent. These young adult transitions (which were broadly similar across BMI trajectory groups) appeared key to weight changes for many participants, regardless of BMI trajectory group ( table 5 ; see online supplementary table S5 ). Thus, across the groups, some described college/university as a fresh start and/or facilitator to exercise which then meant they met active peers. A few learnt about nutrition or PA, enabling reflection on personal choices. However, others felt college/university was connected with weight-gain, mainly via poor diet and alcohol. Employment was also described as both facilitating and impeding weight loss. Several described loss resulting from active jobs and a few used their earnings to join a gym. However, others worked in sedentary jobs, felt too exhausted by work to bother with home cooking or exercise, or spent their earnings on ‘junk’ food and alcohol. Leaving home was also linked to increased dietary control and so healthier options for some but less balanced meals for others; the small number living with a partner described this as increasing the likelihood of home-cooking.
Illustrative quotes according to participant ‘slimmer’, ‘relapser’, ‘stable’ and ‘gainer’ categorisation—young adult transitions
Slimmers | |
Catherine | WORK: I changed my jobs in August last year, and since then, the amount of weight I have lost is unbelievable. I think I've lost about a stone and a half since August … it's just through daen more, being more active, than compared to what I was doing |
Scott | EDUCATION: The lifestyle wasn't so much a big thing about until I turned maybe eighteen, nineteen and started doing my degree then I started learning how to use a gym properly and what sort of exercise that I can do and just I'm now very aware of cos I'm working in nutrition what it is I actually take in and what it is I actually expend |
Relapsers | |
Donna | EDUCATION/LEAVING HOME: That wasn't actually so much of a help because I was living on my own. At student houses and everything else and takeaways was a much more tempting option than cooking for yourself more often than not. Again throughout my Uni career, first to fourth year, I gradually, I definitely improved. I got a grip of that and decided that eating healthy was, was the best option so I started cooking for myself |
Stable | |
Chris | EDUCATION/LEAVING HOME: When I was at uni and I joined the gym and pretty much spent all the money I had on cigarettes and alcohol and didn't eat as much as probably I should have, but not in a you, know, not in a deliberate way, just like I used to never have any money for food and so I lost quite a lot of weight then |
Gainers | |
Jamie | EDUCATION: There was first, first and second year at Uni when I just, you know I discovered you know booze. And then that really was us off to the races in terms of overweight |
Neil | WORK: I was labouring for a wee while. I must have laboured for about six months. … I didn't try to lose weight, when I started the job, I didn't try to lose weight, initially, at all—it didn't enter my mind. … then it became, for me, at my work, at my workplace, where I could be getting paid for losing weight, basically |
Among the ‘slimmers’, Charlie, Clare, Mark and Scott all described weight loss associated with attending university. Charlie's close friends also went to the gym, while Mark was encouraged by a coach; for him ‘ coming to uni was the sort of the biggest change ever ’. When Eilidh started university, she ‘ just started really healthy eating ’ and took up swimming. Catherine and Scott's courses involved nutrition, with Catherine noting ‘ it kinda opens your eyes to things that you're eating and what it is doing to you ’. Weight loss was a requirement for Alan's admission to the RAF and Emma's police job, and their subsequent training involved PA. Both had maintained weights well below the adult obesity level, but Emma described consciously relaxing her regime since achieving her goal of becoming a police officer. Janine had worked as a show dancer, which required physical fitness, but also encouraged high levels of social drinking, ‘ so it was a bit of both—bad and good ’. Catherine had recently left a job at a fast food counter and ‘ the amount of weight I have lost is unbelievable ’.
‘Relapsers’ and those for whom our measurements showed ‘stable’ BMIs provided largely similar accounts. Patricia and Chris described losing weight at university, Patricia by meal-skipping attributed to a busy routine and Chris because he ‘ pretty much spent all the money I had on cigarettes and alcohol and didn't eat as much as probably I should have ’. Donna dealt with university workload stress by eating, and in student accommodation ‘ takeaways was a much more tempting option than cooking for yourself ’. Although several ‘relapsers’ mentioned gym attendance, Chris was the only one who linked this with university. Philip lost weight after leaving school without conscious effort because ‘ I was working full-time. … I wasn't able to go to like Gregg's [bakers] twice a day and stuff like that ’. Christina thought she had lost weight ‘ by accident ’ due to stress and other changes involved in moving into her own home, while living with a friend/partner had forced Malcolm and Philip to begin home cooking.
Weight loss facilitated by young adult transitions was also mentioned by some ‘gainers’: Jamie attended the gym and dieted during his third university year and that was ‘ probably the best shape I was in ’ and Richard attributed weight loss at college to football and gym attendance. Neil found he ‘ could be getting paid for losing weight ’ while working as a building labourer for 6 months. He also ascribed weight fluctuations to his relationship status: ‘ whenever I meet a lassie I'll be in tip top condition and then, within a year I've put on like a stone and a half’. Sarah thought her current nursing job meant ‘ I can't really preach healthy living to people if I'm not actually doing it myself ’. However, accounts in this group also tended to describe transition-related barriers to weight loss. Jamie ‘ discovered booze ’ at university ‘ and then that really was us off to the races in terms of overweight ’. Other ‘gainers’ described the impact of shift-work, on diet (‘ no eating breakfast again, and grabbing a bar of chocolate ’—Kirsty) and motivation to exercise (‘ after a day's work I'm absolutely knackered and I don't want to go out for a run ’—Matthew).
Studies that track from adolescence into adulthood are relatively rare. In our sample of previously overweight or obese adolescents, over a third had not gone on to become obese adults, but almost a quarter were already morbidly obese. The interviews revealed clearly that, contrasting with the recalled lack of concern in mid-adolescence, 20 weight-related concerns and/or desire to lose weight generally increased around the time of school-leaving and most participants described some form of both exercise (formal/informal) and dietary weight-control strategies. These changes may have partly resulted from increasing autonomy (independent/voluntary functioning), 25 self-determination 26 or self-esteem 27 with age: many participants described perceiving postschool transitions as a fresh start and acknowledgement of weight as personal responsibility; most had left the parental home and controlled their own diet and leisure activities.
Differences between ‘slimmers’ and those who had become or remained obese were subtle and hard to detect, even using qualitative methods. A qualitative study of 22 US overweight adolescents, identified via health centre records, found those whose BMI decreased over a 2-year period were more likely to describe ‘transformative experiences’ and family support as well as intense daily exercise. 4 Other qualitative studies have identified successful weight loss maintenance strategies including dietary change, ‘overwhelmingly increased’ exercise and rigorous self-correction after going ‘off course’ among US 14–20 years with sustained weight loss, 28 and a ‘healthy obsession’ with monitoring food, activity and weight among eight formerly obese US adolescents who had attended an immersion treatment. 29 A qualitative study of 20 overweight Taiwanese nursing students highlighted ‘the struggle’, of continuing to practise a new lifestyle and so reducing/maintaining bodyweight. 30 These findings are consistent with suggestions in our data of lifestyle changes becoming habitual and/or part of identity among ‘slimmers’, and of their appearing more likely to self-monitor diet and PA.
Few participants described receiving professional support and, although numbers are small, diet clubs seemed to have been used most by ‘gainers’. In contrast, ‘slimmers’ had achieved weight loss, without support, sometimes fairly easily. A previous qualitative study of obese Australian adults similarly found that few received long-term professional guidance or support as adolescents. 31 Although important for adolescent weight loss, 4 28 it has been suggested that exercise is less acceptable as a weight-loss solution because it is perceived as harder, 31 yet in this study, slimmers commonly used and sustained exercise as a method of weight-control and did not generally describe it as hard.
Our analysis highlights complex relationships between postschool transitions and weight-control behaviours. University/college, work and independent living were each described as facilitating weight losses by some and increases by others. Analysis of US longitudinal youth survey data has identified subgroups with distinctive patterns of weight-gain risk at different periods from middle-school to work/family formation. 32 Other studies have found evidence of declines in PA, increases in alcohol consumption and poor nutrition at University 33–35 36 and in young adulthood, 37 38 but these life-stages have not previously been described before as promoting weight loss. Relationships have also been found between obesity and work conditions including long hours, but again not weight loss. 39
The main strength of this paper is its objective categorisation of participants as ‘slimmer’, ‘gainer’, etc, based on (measured) BMI at several points throughout adolescence. The threshold used in childhood (95th centile) is not a stringent definition of childhood obesity, though widely used for public health analyses. 40 When compared with the more stringent clinical definition of obesity, 40 the 98th centile (Z score 2, equivalent to BMI of about 30 at age 20), nine of the participants were only overweight as adolescents, but it is of note that five of these went on to be obese as adults. Several not categorised as ‘slimmers’ or ‘relapsers’ also mentioned weight loss, not detected by our measurement schedule. Gaps and possible weight changes between measurements, and the sometimes vague nature of participants' recollections mean that precise chronological mapping of these against weight changes is impossible. As the original study did not set out to specifically identify some of the themes highlighted here, particularly professional support, identity and vigilance, we cannot know if other participants might have discussed these issues had the interview included them. The fact they emerged spontaneously is a strength, but because they were not a consistent focus of the study, conclusions on differences between the BMI trajectory groups must remain tentative. However, future research on late adolescent/young adult weight-related concerns, behaviours and experiences could explore these issues more explicitly. Another limitation of all interview data is that participants might have been providing acceptable ‘public’ accounts to a public health researcher 41 about a stigmatised issue. 42 43
In conclusion, this exploratory paper adds insights on experiences of obesity and weight loss during a rarely studied life-stage when research participants are hard to access. In contrast to their recollections of adolescence, as young adults even the heaviest participants tended to show contemplation or preparation for weight-loss action. 12 13 Although there were few really distinctive differences between those who successfully lost weight and those who became ever more obese, their accounts suggest the importance of social context and highlight potential health-change opportunities during the transition to adulthood. This could be a key life-stage for interventions, which should include workplace and educational 44 settings.
The authors would like to thank the young people, nurse interviewers, schools and all those involved in the West of Scotland 11-16/16+Study.
Contributors: HS and CW conceived the research questions and analysis, ES gathered the data as part of a wider study. JN identified relevant themes, CW categorised participants on the basis of their adolescent and age 24 BMIs, HS identified relevant literature and first-drafted the paper. All authors contributed to subsequent redrafts.
Funding: HS is funded by the MRC at the MRC/CSO Social and Public Health Sciences Unit, University of Glasgow (MC_UU_12017/12 and SPHSU12). These data were gathered by ES while funded by a UK Medical Research Council (MRC) PhD studentship. JN was funded by a small grant from a Feeding Research Fund held by CW. CW is funded by Glasgow University and NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde.
Competing interests: None declared.
Ethics approval: Approval to conduct each stage of the 11-16/16+ Study was given by the University of Glasgow Ethics Committee for Non-Clinical Research Involving Human Subjects; approval for the qualitative substudy was obtained from the University of Glasgow Law, Business, and Social Science Faculty Ethics Committee.
Provenance and peer review: Not commissioned; externally peer reviewed.
Data sharing statement: The current MRC/CSO Social and Public Health Sciences Unit Data Sharing Policy does not cover data collected by research students. Anyone with a particular interest in this qualitative data set should contact HS.
There’s mounting evidence that artificial sweeteners may be linked to heart disease and other possible health risks. Scientists say the findings are far from definitive, however, with some leading researchers calling for better-designed clinical trials investigating the long-term health effects of sugar substitutes.
That’s why, in separate trials, researchers are actively working to get a clearer understanding of how artificial sweeteners affect blood glucose levels, gut microbiome health and the cardiovascular system. Some studies are beginning to compare the alternatives against each other, while others hope to learn how they affect the body compared to sugar.
As it is, it’s difficult for consumers to determine which sugar alternative carries the fewest health risks. Most of the research is observational , meaning it doesn’t prove cause and effect. In some cases, researchers looked at people who ate nonsugar sweeteners, analyzed their incidence of certain health risks like heart attacks or diabetes, then noted associations between the two.
All the widely consumed alternatives such as saccharin, aspartame, sucralose, stevia, xylitol and erythritol are approved by the Food and Drug Administration. They’re found in countless products including sports drinks, energy bars, yogurts, cereals, beverages, candies, baked goods and syrups.
Even with FDA approval, Dr. Dariush Mozaffarian, a cardiologist and professor of nutrition science and policy at Tufts University, said “they’re all potentially worrisome and all understudied.”
In recent research, cardiologist Dr. Stanley Hazen at the Cleveland Clinic found that the high concentrations of the sugar alcohol sweeteners xylitol and erythritol may cause the platelets in the blood to become more sticky and prone to clotting, in turn raising the risk of heart attack and stroke. The phenomenon is similar to what happens with high cholesterol, Hazen said. If they get big enough, the clots can block blood flow through crucial veins and arteries.
Some experts say that instead of trying to pinpoint the safest nonsugar sweetener, better studies need to determine whether there’s a benefit to swapping out sugar in the first place.
After publishing research finding a connection between erythritol and increased risk of heart attack and stroke , Hazen and his colleagues conducted the first head-to-head human trial comparing the effects of consuming erythritol versus sugar on the blood platelets that control clotting. The results of that study are pending publication.
Vasanti Malik, an assistant professor of nutritional sciences at the University of Toronto, meanwhile, is conducting a study of more than 500 people directly comparing the health effects of drinking sugar-sweetened beverages, noncaloric sweeteners or water. Malik and her colleagues plan to measure obesity and heart health over time.
At Virginia Tech, registered dietitian Valisa Hedrick is working with the National Institutes of Health on another study comparing the effects of four different artificial sweeteners versus sugar on blood glucose levels and gut microbiome health. The study, which focuses on people with prediabetes, is a controlled feeding trial, meaning participants only eat the meals that NIH provides them, and nothing more.
This is important, Hedrick said, because one of the growing concerns with nonsugar sweeteners is that the products trick the brain in such a way that they increase sugar cravings. People may then end up eating more sugar throughout the day, spiking their blood glucose.
With a controlled study, the researchers can answer whether the sweeteners themselves raise blood glucose directly — not the sugar people could otherwise eat later.
A research bias called reverse causation can make it difficult to draw decisive conclusions from prior studies, Malik said.
People often change their diets after they start developing diabetes or putting on weight, Malik said. These people, generally, are most likely to switch from sugar to nonsugar sweeteners. This is where the reverse causation comes into play.
“You get a spurious association between the intake of nonsugar sweeteners and the risk for diabetes,” she said. That is, the data ends up suggesting that these sweeteners are causing health problems that already existed.
Many studies also rely on people to report whether they’ve consumed nonsugar substitutes, which can be unreliable. Names like xylitol can be buried in a long list of ingredients.
Other studies, meanwhile — like Hazen’s erythritol and xylitol studies — may focus directly on what happens in the body after someone consumes one of these sweeteners, but they tend to enroll small numbers of people and track them only for a short time.
“A lot of these studies are really hard to interpret,” said Dr. Michelle Pearlman, a gastroenterologist and the CEO and co-founder of the Prime Institute in Miami. “And the problem is that there’s no head-to-head trials of people eating candy bars versus xylitol, so I can’t make any blanket statements recommending one or the other.”
Both Hedrick and Malik hope to share results from their respective studies in the next several years.
“We need experimental science alongside more rigorous observational research,” Malik said. “There are trials underway, and I think in the next five years we’ll have more clarity on the topic. We’re just not quite there.”
In a statement, the Calorie Control Council, an industry trade group representing more than two dozen sweetener manufacturers, said studies linking alternative sweeteners to health risks are based on flawed research and that the products are safe.
“It is irresponsible to amplify faulty research to those who look to alternative sweeteners to reduce overall sugar intake as well as the millions who use it as a tool to manage their health conditions, including obesity and diabetes,” Carla Saunders, the trade group’s president, said in the statement.
Most low-calorie and sugar-free foods contain at least one sugar substitute, and many contain several. These products are growing more popular, especially in the U.S. By 2033, market research suggests sugar substitutes could be worth more than $28.57 billion.
“They’re ubiquitous,” Mozafarrian said. “And they’re proliferating because people have become so obsessed with avoiding sugar.”
Mozaffarian said these sweeteners soared in popularity following changes to U.S. nutrition labeling requirements in 2016 .
The change required manufacturers to list added sugars on a separate line beneath total sugars. The idea was to help consumers differentiate between foods with naturally occurring sugars, like fruit and plain Greek yogurt, and foods that had sugars mixed in.
“Now, the food industry has a big incentive to make that ‘added sugars’ number as small as possible,” he said. “So you’re seeing these compounds in everything, and we still don’t have enough information on them.”
Some products are labeled as “artificial sweeteners” or “natural sweeteners” based on whether they’re derived from natural sources or chemically engineered.
Even natural sweeteners go through heavy chemical processing, said Dr. Maria Carolina Delgado-Lelievre, a cardiologist at the University of Miami.
For example, stevia comes from processed stevia plant extract, monk fruit sweetener comes from processing a chemical in a gourdlike fruit grown in China, and sucralose is a chemically altered version of sugar about 600 times sweeter, according to the FDA .
Aspartame and saccharin are from human-made fusions of amino acids and chemicals.
Many of these sweeteners are so potent in tiny quantities that they’re mixed with xylitol or erythritol to bulk them up and fill a packet, said the Cleveland Clinic’s Hazen.
Given this label confusion, Hedrick said researchers are increasingly using the term “nonsugar sweeteners.”
Sugar, of course, is one of the country’s most pressing public health problems. Especially in soda and juice, excess sugar fuels the ongoing obesity epidemic , contributing to heart disease, liver disease, cancer and diabetes .
However, there’s a big difference between processed, concentrated sugars like high-fructose corn syrup and the natural sugars found in fruits, Pearlman, the Miami gastroenterologist, said. Processed sugars are highly addictive.
“Anything with high-fructose corn syrup stimulates the same reward centers in our brain as cocaine and heroin,” she said. “Natural sugars from fruit act differently in the body.”
Sugar’s bad rap has much more to do with the quantity people consume than any intrinsically bad property, experts agree.
“Added sugar is nuanced,” Mozaffarian said. “When you try to take that very real nuance and turn it into a simple message, you get the industry misleading consumers that foods are ‘not good.’”
A little bit of added sugar in otherwise healthy foods, he said — such as lightly sweetened whole-grain cereals — is usually OK.
“The harms of these different nonsugar sweeteners have been greatly underemphasized and the harms of small amounts of added sugar have been overemphasized,” he argued.
The U.S. government’s Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend that anyone over the age of 2 consume less than 10% of their daily calories from added sugar, or the equivalent of roughly 12 teaspoons of added sugar. In reality, as of 2018, people in the U.S., including children, were consuming about 17 teaspoons of added sugar per day, on average.
Recently, the U.S. Department of Agriculture implemented a new rule limiting added sugars in public school lunches . Michael Goran, a professor of pediatrics at the University of Southern California’s Keck School of Medicine, said he worries that schools will replace sugary foods with artificially sweetened foods to comply with the new rules.
“There’s this general perception that these sweeteners are safe alternatives, but if they’re broadly applied to children, I unfortunately think that’s very risky,” he said.
Mozaffarian said that at their current levels of added sugar, most yogurts would no longer be allowed in school lunches once the new rule goes into effect.
“They’re just above the new limit, so it’s likely these yogurts are now going to be made with a series of sweeteners with uncertain health effects,” Mozaffarian said.
In the meantime, Pearlman said, it’s easy to see they haven’t helped the population become healthier on the whole.
“We have more chronic disease, more diabetes today than we’ve ever had before,” she said. “That shows that despite the diet industry being worth billions of dollars, we’re clearly missing the ball.”
A confusing body of limited research, coupled with the lack of clarity on food labels, puts consumers in a tough position when it comes to selecting the healthiest choices, the experts concluded.
All agreed on the best solution:
“If I had the choice of eating a store-bought cookie with a lot of sweeteners in it, a store-bought cookie with monk fruit, or a homemade cookie with sugar, I would choose the homemade cookie,” Goran said. “You can still enjoy the cookie, but maybe put a little less sugar in there.”
NBC News contributor Caroline Hopkins is a health and science journalist who covers cancer treatment for Precision Oncology News. She is a graduate of the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism.
IMAGES
VIDEO
COMMENTS
In the United States, overweight and obesity are chronic diseases that contribute to excess morbidity and mortality. Despite public health efforts, these disorders are on the rise, and their consequences are burgeoning. 1 The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention report that during 2017 to 2018, the prevalence of obesity in the United States was 42.4%, which was increased from the ...
Answer. Kent, It depends on the question you are asking. Our lab studies the effects of maternal high fat diet on DOHaD in offspring. Others use a Western diet (high fat and carbohydrates). There ...
Obesity has become a global epidemic and is one of today's most public health problems worldwide. Obesity poses a major risk for a variety of serious diseases including diabetes mellitus, non-alcoholic liver disease (NAFLD), cardiovascular disease, hypertension and stroke, and certain forms of cancer (Bluher, 2019).Obesity is mainly caused by imbalanced energy intake and expenditure due to a ...
Answer #2: Overconsumption. There are two reasons for the chronic overconsumption of calories. First, the more fat-cells an individual has, the more calories s/he will store as fat after each meal. Yet if more calories are stored as fat, less calories are available to keep other cells alive. Therefore, excess calories must be consumed to ...
Objectives To identify and prioritise the most impactful, unanswered questions for obesity and weight-related research. Design Prioritisation exercise of research questions using online surveys and an independently facilitated workshop. Setting Online/virtual. Participants We involved members of the public including people living with obesity, researchers, healthcare professionals and policy ...
14 answers. Feb 11, 2014. Obese women have an increased risk of pregnancy-related complications, including hypertension, gestational diabetes, and blood clots. Maternal obesity is also known to be ...
Current research on obesity and sleep. An NHLBI-funded study is looking at whether energy balance and obesity affect sleep in the same way that a lack of good-quality sleep affects obesity. The researchers are recruiting equal numbers of men and women to include sex differences in their study of how obesity affects sleep quality and circadian ...
Some genetic and lifestyle factors affect an individual's likelihood of adult obesity; thus, the significant clusters of obesity observed in specific geographical regions and contexts also signal the impact of socioeconomic and environmental factors in "obesogenic" environments [13].Understanding the causes and determinants of obesity is a critical step toward creating effective policy and ...
This is the resource for finding original, comprehensive reporting and analysis to get background information on issues in the news. It provides overviews of topics related to health, social trends, criminal justice, international affairs, education, the environment, technology, and the economy in America. Gale eBooks.
The Strategic Plan for NIH Obesity Research serves as a guide to accelerate a broad spectrum of research toward developing new and more effective approaches to address the tremendous burden of obesity, so that people can look forward to healthier lives. The Plan was originally published in 2011. In 2018-2019, the Obesity Research Task Force ...
Research in the area of obesity has tended towards measurable outcomes and quantitative variables that fail to capture the complexity associated with the experience of obesity. A need to rethink how we approach obesity has been identified—one that represents the voices and experiences of people living with obesity.
Obesity and Nutrition. More than one-third of U.S. adults — and about 17 percent of U.S. children — are obese. Obesity puts people at risk for many health issues including heart disease, stroke, type 2 diabetes, arthritis, and certain types of cancer. Because these conditions are some of the top preventable causes of chronic illness and ...
Envision is a research network of 11 funded teams and a host of affiliate members who have worked together to address obesity-related research questions with systems science methods and advanced statistical techniques to identify the drivers of obesity and the leverage points and policies with greatest potential to reverse the tide. A key ...
Asking Hard Questions. Considering all this, we need to ask hard questions about what we think we know about obesity. 1. How can we know that? For instance, how can we be more confident of dietary factors that contribute to obesity. Presumptions and logic are not good enough. 2.
Obesity. The NIH supports obesity research across the lifespan, examining the causes and consequences of obesity, developing and evaluating new prevention and treatment strategies, and determining how to implement and expand promising approaches to reach those who could most benefit.
Childhood obesity outline example. As the question of childhood obesity is a specific one, it would differ from the outline on obesity we presented previously. Here is a sample you might need. The topic covers general research on child obesity. Introduction. Hook sentence. Thesis statement. Transition to Main Body. Main Body. The problem of ...
This essay shall discuss the health issue of obesity, a social health problem that is, unfortunately, growing at a rapid rate. Obesity in Hispanic American Citizens. The issue of obesity anong Hispanic Americans occurs as a result of poor dieting choices caused by misinformed perceptions of proper eating.
1. Introduction. Purposeful weight loss continues to be the primary focus for treating obesity. Behavioral recommendations for weight loss include lifestyle modifications that reduce caloric intake from diet and increase caloric output with increased physical activity [1,2].However, this strategy appears to be inadequate as obesity rates continue to rise and the myriad of benefits of physical ...
Obesity is the main nutritional problem and one of the most important health problems in developed societies. Central to the challenge of obesity prevention and management is a thoroughly understanding of its determinants. Multiple socio-cultural, socio-economic, behavioural and biological factors-- …
Obesity is a chronic, progressive pathology that has no cure and requires specific treatment to lose weight and continuous follow-up to avoid weight regain. There are several treatments for obesity but none of them cures it definitively. Unfortunately, physiological adaptations to weight loss favor weight regain.
Objectives: To identify and prioritise the most impactful, unanswered questions for obesity and weight-related research. Design: Prioritisation exercise of research questions using online surveys and an independently facilitated workshop. Setting: Online/virtual. Participants: We involved members of the public including people living with obesity, researchers, healthcare professionals and ...
Obesity and mental health. People with obesity are at higher risk for mood and anxiety disorders. One study found that those with obesity were 55% more likely than others to develop depression ...
Frequently asked questions about BMI, including how it is used and how it should be interpreted. ... For most people, BMI is a good indicator of whether they have too much or too little body fat. However, BMI is not a direct measure of body fat. ... Obesity during childhood or teenage years is associated with various physical and mental health ...
Constructing and parsing a research question Boolean logic Proximity operators Field searching Controlled vocabularies and database structure ... Home → Services → Library Training & Events → Instruction Menu → Asking a Good Questions and Preparing to Search. Asking a Good Questions and Preparing to Search Constructing and parsing a ...
Introduction. Adolescent overweight is associated with greatly increased likelihood of adult obesity, 1 but up to a third of obese adolescents do not go on to be obese adults. 2 What is not clear is why and how some overweight/obese adolescents (defined broadly, by the WHO, as those aged 10-19 3) lose weight and others do not, 4 and why some adolescents maintain weight loss while others ...
A research bias called reverse causation can make it difficult to draw decisive conclusions from prior studies, Malik said. People often change their diets after they start developing diabetes or ...
The transferability of polygenic scores across population groups is a major concern with respect to the equitable clinical implementation of genomic medicine. Since genetic associations are identified relative to the population mean, inevitably differences in disease or trait prevalence among social strata influence the relationship between PGS and risk.